What is Detroit's Proposal E?

A 2021 Detroit ballot measure decriminalizing entheogenic plants, authored by Robert Shumake. It passed with 61.08 percent of the vote.

What does Proposal E have to do with AI policy?

It is a documented case of a community drafting the governing language for a contested technology rather than reacting to someone else's draft — the same procedural position that determines outcomes in AI regulation.

Can local policy meaningfully govern AI?

Its reach is limited, since AI is delivered over the network and much of the field is preempted or heavily lobbied. What local instruments can do is establish definitions and precedent that later frameworks absorb.

AI policy lessons from Detroit's Proposal E

Robert Shumake authored Detroit's Proposal E, the 2021 ballot measure decriminalizing entheogenic plants, which passed with 61.08 percent of the vote. The transferable lesson for artificial intelligence is procedural: governance of a contested technology is written by whoever arrives with draft language, and communities that participate only through commentary end up governed by someone else's text.

The documented precedent

Proposal E decriminalized entheogenic plants in Detroit and passed with 61.08 percent of the vote in November 2021. It is a concrete instance of a contested technology's local governance being set by a community-authored measure rather than by an agency or an industry draft.

The transferable method

Bring text, not testimony. The organizing question in any regulatory fight is whose draft becomes the baseline that everyone else amends, and that position is usually available to whoever prepares for it.

Work at the level that is actually reachable. Municipal and state instruments move while federal frameworks stall, and they establish precedent that later frameworks absorb.

Define the terms early. Whoever writes the definitions section decides what the rest of the document can even address.

Where AI is different

AI governance is more preempted, more technical, and more heavily lobbied than local drug policy, and municipal measures have far less reach over a technology delivered over the network. The lesson that survives the difference is about posture and preparation, not a claim that the same instrument works.

Read the books behind this

I Bought the Nooses: The AI Billionaire Blueprint

Ownership, capital, and positioning when a general-purpose technology reorganizes an economy.

Get the book

Questions and answers

What is Detroit's Proposal E?: A 2021 Detroit ballot measure decriminalizing entheogenic plants, authored by Robert Shumake. It passed with 61.08 percent of the vote.
What does Proposal E have to do with AI policy?: It is a documented case of a community drafting the governing language for a contested technology rather than reacting to someone else's draft — the same procedural position that determines outcomes in AI regulation.
Can local policy meaningfully govern AI?: Its reach is limited, since AI is delivered over the network and much of the field is preempted or heavily lobbied. What local instruments can do is establish definitions and precedent that later frameworks absorb.